48 Comments
User's avatar
TheEliad's avatar

This was bold and needed. Thankyou x

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

thank you for reading!

Chanti's avatar

I really agree with your critique of “problem-solving” as manufactured wound + offered fix.

I do wonder if there’s a quieter form of helping that isn’t about fixing at all; naming something someone already feels and staying with them in it, without optimizing them out of it.

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

that’s an interesting thought!

Constantin Diessner's avatar

Appreciate this! I started out writing personal branding content, gravitated towards long-form stuff. It's the slower, more genuine path.

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

glad you came to the same conclusion!

Dario Archer's avatar

ahh. to monetize or not monetize..

that is the question….

for some.

Dario Archer's avatar

i have never looked at my subscribers, i do not want to post as if im expected to; i have yet to post any of my “words” of which i have poems, essays, and a book on the stove percolating; i’ve never done the “drop your stack and i’ll do same..

so answer is no.

hold a bird in an open hand.

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

what’s your answer?

The Negentrop's avatar

That’s not far off of the idea I expressed about identity. Good work with a fun aggressive bite

The Negentrop's avatar

My strange edges are the only advantage I have lol, my strength

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

thank you! i’ll be checking it out

Buket Elena's avatar

I literally did write about how niche-ism flatting what it means to be a human. I agree with you ❣️

Will Walker's avatar

If you deal with people, they don’t want to put you in a frame. Commercialization was the worst thing to happen to a creative 😭😭

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

couldn’t agree more!!

Jennifer Riggan's avatar

Yes! Love this! Thought you might appreciate my piece on the same thing. Enjoy! https://open.substack.com/pub/jenniferriggan/p/forging-a-brand?r=1fojb2&utm_medium=ios&shareImageVariant=overlay

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

read your piece immediately and thought it was great! thanks for sharing

ThePrivatePracticePsychologist's avatar

As a new writer to Substack, this so resonates with me. Thank you for your words and message 💛

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

So happy to hear it! 🫶🏼

Gabrielle Denman's avatar

Love this, beautiful written and I feel this deeply too.

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

thank you so much! I appreciate it 💌

Gabrielle Denman's avatar

🩷

Notes from the In-Between's avatar

“I am a soul, I am a writer. I want to seduce you with my words, make you stay with my charms. And you, dear reader, are supposed to unwrap me, layer by layer. Keep what resonates, discard what doesn’t.” ⭐️⭐️ love this, the entire piece . Very well done

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

thank you so much! 😊💌🫶🏼

Lee Azevado's avatar

This was music to my ears, I left Medium because it felt saturated with personal brands and marketers selling success stories, there's still some of that here, but here there seems a lot more authentic creatives, such as yourself, def had to subscribe to you after reading this!

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

thank you so much! That means a lot to me 💌

An Olive Daily's avatar

Yes yes yes yes I couldn’t agree more

Caitlin A. Smith's avatar

Really love this.

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

thank you!

RandomSyllables's avatar

This is something I have been feeling, thinking, at times trying to articulate.

I am tired of being told to choose a niche or a genre or stick to it.

I write a story. There are tropes. But I don't create a check list of the best tropes to use or flip. I don't advertise my story with a descriptive title, a cover showing all the characters, and a blurb that talks more about what the protagonist gains than the obstacles they face. I am sick of having to tell people if my story has a happy ending or not. I want them to find out. I want them to feel the suspense in each chapter, not knowing anyone's ultimate fate.

Thank you for writing this.

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

Thank you so much for reading! I can tell you feel strongly about it, too. Let’s not give up doing things our way!

bigandsmallreads's avatar

I really hate the term ‘personal brand’

Hannah Jay.'s avatar

i’m sick of it too 🙂‍↕️😂😭